Get matched with the best Roofing & Gutter Service pros in Shelter Island, NY

Find licensed roofers and gutter specialists near you. Get free quotes for roof repair, shingle replacement, and gutter installation.

Browse all services
Retaining Wall Construction
Window Installation & Replacement
Roofing & Gutter Services
Siding & Exterior Remodeling
Solar Panel Installation Services
Pest Control Services
Septic Tank & Septic System Services
Garage Door Installation & Repair
Insulation Installation
Foundation Installation & Repair
Basement Waterproofing
Landscape Design
Landscape Construction
Landscape Maintenance
Landscape Repair
Land Cleaning
Garden Remodeling
Tree Planting & Transplanting
Tree & Shrub Care
Lawn Care & Mowing
Lawn Edging & Trimming
Leaf Removal & Cleanup
Seasonal Yard Cleaning
Lawn Aeration
Lawn Dethatching
Lawn Overseeding & Reseeding
Patio Design & Installation
Paver Installation
Driveway Repair & Paving
Deck Building & Repair
Sidewalk & Pathway Installation
Fence Installation
Stone & Concrete Installation
Outdoor Lighting Installation
Sprinkler Installation & Repair
Sprinkler Adjustment
Drip Irrigation System Installation
Irrigation System Repair
Rainwater Harvesting System Installation
Drought-Resistant Lawn Installation
Handyman Services
Air Duct Cleaning Services
Door Installation & Replacement
Drywall Installation & Repair
House Painting Services
Kitchen Remodeling
Interior Design & Decorating
Custom Cabinets & Cabinetry
Countertop Installation Services
Flooring Installation Services
Tile & Stone Installation Services
Carpet Installation
Bathroom Remodeling
Walk-In Tub Installation
Home Renovation & Remodeling Services
Design-Build Services
Custom Home Builders
Commercial Construction Services
Carpentry & Woodworking
Architectural & Building Design Services
Structural Engineering Services
Heating & Cooling Services
Electrical Services
Plumbing Services
Smart Home & Theater Installers
Professional Home Organizers
Junk Removal & Hauling
Please tell us the project that you need help with

Gutter Helmet By Harry Helmet

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4.7 (42 reviews)
Bohemia, NY 11716

Gutter Helmet by Harry Helmet® offers professional installation of its innovative gutter protection system over existing rain gutters. Designed to prevent clogs and costly damage, Gutter Helmet® is ma...

A1 Roofing & Siding

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4.7 (15 reviews)
Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776
4 projects

A1 Roofing & Siding is a family-owned company serving Long Island since 1981. We pride ourselves on our expertise and commitment to quality without sales gimmicks or hidden costs. Our OSHA-compliant t...

SixM Construction Inc.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4.7 (15 reviews)
Belle Terre, NY
4 projects

SixM Construction Inc. is a family-owned business proudly serving the Long Island community for nearly 30 years. We specialize in exterior home improvement projects and are fully licensed and insured...

Anthony's Roofing Corp

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4.6 (13 reviews)
Bohemia, NY 11716
17 projects

Anthony's Roofing Corp is a trusted leader in residential roofing, recognized as Best of L.I. for multiple years and a GAF Master Elite installer. We offer lifetime warranties on complete roofing syst...

Sav A Roof Inc.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4.6 (13 reviews)
Southampton, NY
2 projects

Sav A Roof Inc. has been Long Island's leading custom roofing provider for over 25 years, serving both residential and commercial clients. We pride ourselves on delivering exceptional customer service...

Montauk Point Roofing

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4.6 (11 reviews)
Montauk, NY

Montauk Point Roofing, located in Montauk, NY, specializes in high-quality roofing solutions for residential and commercial properties. Our team of experienced professionals is dedicated to delivering...

Tend Home Improvement INC

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4.7 (10 reviews)
Shirley, NY 11967

Tend Home Improvement Inc, located in Shirley, NY, specializes in a wide range of home improvement services. Our dedicated team is committed to enhancing the beauty and functionality of your space thr...

Skylights Of Long Island Plus

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4.8 (9 reviews)
Bellport, NY
13 projects

Skylights of Long Island Plus specializes in skylight installation, sales, and replacement services. Our team is dedicated to enhancing your space with high-quality skylights that provide natural ligh...

R W Mulligan Co Inc

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4.8 (8 reviews)
Riverhead, NY 11901
1 project

R W Mulligan Co Inc, located in Riverhead, NY, is dedicated to delivering high-quality products and services. With a commitment to excellence and customer satisfaction, we strive to meet the diverse n...

Empire Gen Roofing And Chimney

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4.7 (7 reviews)
Center Moriches, NY 11934

Empire Gen Roofing and Chimney has been a trusted provider of roofing and chimney services in Long Island for over 25 years. As a family-owned business, we specialize in roof repair, replacement, and...

Verified Reviews for Roofing & Gutter Services pros in Shelter Island, NY

*The Growcycle rating for Roofing & Gutter Services companies in Shelter Island, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Roofing & Gutter Services needs.

Last update on July 12, 2026

Larry Henderson

Reviewed in January 2026

I was really impressed with the quality of the installation and the professionalism of the team. My gutters are now worry-free and protected from clogs. Highly recommend this service!

Gutter Helmet by Harry Helmet - Roofing & Gutter Services in Shelter Island, NY Gutter Helmet by Harry Helmet Request a quote

Emily Johnson

Reviewed in November 2025

I had a fantastic experience with my recent roof replacement. The team was professional and finished the job ahead of schedule. Highly recommend their services!

Montauk Point Roofing - Roofing & Gutter Services in Shelter Island, NY Montauk Point Roofing Request a quote

Jessica Lee

Reviewed in January 2026

The team provided excellent service and quality work. They were friendly and answered all my questions without hesitation. Definitely worth the investment for a new roof.

Supra Roofing - Roofing & Gutter Services in Shelter Island, NY Supra Roofing Request a quote

Roberta Jones

Reviewed in January 2026

Highly satisfied with my roof replacement! The team was professional, timely, and did excellent work. Would recommend for any roofing needs.

A-List Construction Roofing And Chimney - Roofing & Gutter Services in Shelter Island, NY A-List Construction Roofing And Chimney Request a quote

Sean Gomez

Reviewed in September 2025

Empire Gen Roofing And Chimney did an outstanding job on my roof repair. Professional team and quality work that I can trust!

Empire Gen Roofing and Chimney - Roofing & Gutter Services in Shelter Island, NY Empire Gen Roofing and Chimney Request a quote
Cost Guide

How much does Roofing & Gutter Services cost in Shelter Island, NY?

Typical roofing & gutter services projects in Shelter Island, NY range from $5,500 to $20,000, with most homeowners paying around $10,000.

$5,500
$10,000 Typical cost in Shelter Island, NY
$20,000
LOWHIGH

Prices vary by project scope, materials, and local labor rates.

Per Sq Ft $4–$8
Per Roof $2,500–$15,000
Per Linear Ft $2–$5

Last updated: April 2026

Roofing and gutter services in Shelter Island typically cost between $5,500 and $20,000, with an average price around $10,000. The overall cost can vary based on the roof type, slope, and materials chosen.

Contractors in Shelter Island often charge between $75 and $150 per hour, influenced by their experience and the project's complexity. Local permits are generally needed for roofing projects through the Shelter Island Building Department, which can add a fee of around $300 and may require 2-3 weeks for processing.

When comparing quotes from contractors in Shelter Island, it's vital to check the warranty offered on materials and workmanship. Ensure that all aspects of the project are included in the estimate to avoid any surprise expenses.

When comparing roofing and gutter service quotes in Shelter Island, prioritize understanding the scope of work and warranties to ensure you're getting the best value.

What affects the cost in Shelter Island, NY?

Shelter Island Labor Rates

Licensed roofing contractors in Shelter Island charge $75–$150/hr, reflecting the high demand and specialized skills required. Labor rates can fluctuate based on the nature of the project and seasonal availability.

Permits & Inspections

Most roofing work in Shelter Island requires permits from the Building Department. The permit fee is typically around $300, and approval can take 2-3 weeks, which can affect project timelines.

Material Selection & Quality

Material choice can swing a roofing project by 15-40%. Higher-end materials like slate or metal can significantly increase the cost but may offer longer durability.

Seasonal Demand & Scheduling

Late spring to early fall is the best time for roofing projects in Shelter Island, as weather conditions are more favorable. Booking during the off-season may yield better rates and availability.

Frequently Asked Questions About Roofing & Gutter Services in Shelter Island, NY

Maintaining your gutters is crucial for protecting your Shelter Island home from water damage. Start by regularly cleaning your gutters at least twice a year to remove leaves, twigs, and other debris that can cause clogs. It's best to perform this maintenance in the spring and fall, especially considering the number of trees in the area. Ensure that your downspouts are clear and directing water away from your foundation. After heavy storms, check for any leaks or signs of overflow, as this can indicate a problem. Installing gutter guards can also be a helpful preventive measure, reducing the frequency of cleaning required. Additionally, inspect the gutters for any sagging or damage, which may necessitate repairs or replacement. Consulting with local professionals can provide further guidance on effective gutter maintenance tailored to the unique environmental factors of Shelter Island.

In Shelter Island, it’s recommended to inspect your roof and gutters at least twice a year, ideally in the spring and fall. Seasonal changes can bring about different challenges; for example, autumn leaves can clog gutters, while winter snow and ice can lead to ice dam formation on roofs. Regular inspections help identify potential issues before they become costly repairs. Look for signs of damage such as missing shingles, sagging areas, or rust on gutters. Additionally, after severe storms, it’s wise to conduct a thorough check to ensure your roof and gutters remain intact. Engaging a local professional for these inspections can provide expert insight and ensure that your roofing system is functioning correctly and efficiently. Keeping your roof and gutters in good condition is essential to protect your home from water damage, especially in areas prone to heavy rainfall.

There are several signs that may indicate it’s time for a roof replacement in Shelter Island. One of the most noticeable signs is the age of your roof; if it’s more than 20 years old, it may be nearing the end of its lifespan, depending on the materials used. Look for missing, curling, or cracked shingles, as these can compromise your roof’s integrity. Stains on your ceilings or walls can indicate leaks, which may suggest that your roof is no longer adequately protecting your home. Additionally, if you notice significant granule loss in your gutters or a sagging roofline, these are serious red flags. In Shelter Island's coastal environment, roofs are often subjected to harsh weather conditions, which can accelerate wear and tear. If you observe any of these signs, it’s advisable to consult with a local roofing professional to evaluate your situation and discuss replacement options.

When selecting roofing materials for homes in Shelter Island, it's essential to consider the local climate, which can include both strong winds and heavy precipitation. Asphalt shingles are a popular choice due to their affordability and versatility, but for enhanced durability, metal roofing is gaining traction. Metal roofs can withstand harsh weather, resist rust, and offer excellent longevity. Another option is slate roofing, which is not only aesthetically pleasing but also highly durable, though it comes at a higher price point. Additionally, consider the insulation properties of your roofing material, as effective insulation can help regulate your home's temperature and minimize energy costs. Always consult with local roofing professionals who understand the specific weather challenges in Shelter Island to make an informed decision that balances durability, aesthetics, and budget.

When hiring a roofing contractor in Shelter Island, there are several important factors to consider. Start by checking their licensing and insurance; a reputable contractor should have the necessary permits to work in your area and liability insurance to protect you in case of any accidents. Look for online reviews and ask for references from previous clients to gauge their reputation and reliability. Experience is also crucial; choose a contractor who has been in the industry for several years and is familiar with the roofing materials and methods that work best in Shelter Island's climate. Additionally, get multiple quotes to compare pricing, but be wary of prices that seem too low, as they may indicate subpar workmanship or materials. Finally, ensure that the contractor provides a detailed contract outlining the scope of work, materials to be used, and timelines. A well-informed decision can lead to a successful roofing project that meets your needs and expectations.

Common Roofing & Gutter Services services and their costs

Typical pricing in Shelter Island, NY by service type.

Roof Installation

Primary roofing materials

MethodCost Range
Asphalt Shingle Roofing
A popular and cost-effective roofing option.
$5,000–$15,000
Metal Roofing
Durable and energy-efficient, ideal for coastal climates.
$10,000–$20,000
Slate Roofing
An elegant and long-lasting choice, often used in upscale homes.
$15,000–$30,000
Tile Roofing
A traditional look with excellent durability, suited for Mediterranean styles.
$12,000–$25,000

Gutter Installation & Repair

Essential gutter services

MethodCost Range
Seamless Gutter Installation
Custom gutters that reduce leaks and improve aesthetics.
$1,500–$3,500
Gutter Cleaning
Regular maintenance to prevent clogs and water damage.
$150–$300
Gutter Guard Installation
Protects gutters from debris and minimizes maintenance.
$800–$1,500
Gutter Repair
Fixing leaks and damage to prolong lifespan.
$200–$700
Ready to start your roofing & gutter services project? Get free quotes from vetted pros in Shelter Island, NY.
Get Free Estimates

Price ranges are estimates compiled from publicly available data and may vary with project scope.


Disclaimer: Some information on Growcycle Pros, including company details, projects, and contact information, is gathered from publicly available sources and provided "as is" without guarantees of accuracy or service quality. Growcycle does not endorse or guarantee the quality or reliability of any listed professionals. All trademarks and other intellectual property remain the property of their respective owners.

We use ActiveProspect's TrustedForm script to independently record and verify users' consent to be contacted. The TrustedForm script is embedded on our website and, when you interact with any page where it appears, it collects information such as the page URL; mouse movements and clicks; any contact details entered by the user; a snapshot of the page; the user's IP address; time spent on the page; the date and time the TrustedForm script loaded; timestamps of user interactions; and HTTP headers from the user's browser. For details on ActiveProspect's data collection and use practices, please review the ActiveProspect Privacy Policy.

To schedule a call with this pro, please share a few details about your project.

This will help them understand your needs better.

This service pro offers multiple services
Which service do you need?

What type of project?

What types of repairs or maintenance are needed?

Tell us more

Where is the work area?

Send A Message to the Pro

Ask questions or describe what you need. You don't need to include contact info yet.

0/2000

This service pro offers multiple services
Which service do you need?

Select one to help us match you with the right pro.

When do you need this done?

This helps pros plan their schedule.

Analyzing project details

What's your project address?

This helps us find pros near you.

Your information is secure
Your data is protected with 256-bit AES encryption -- the same military-grade standard used by banks and government agencies.

We have matching pros in your area!

Project: Home Services

By clicking "Next," I consent and provide my electronic signature authorizing Growcycle—and its marketing partners and up to four home improvement companies, and parties acting on their behalf—to contact me at the number provided with marketing calls and texts, including via autodialer, SMS, and artificial or prerecorded voice messages, regarding current and future projects. Consent is not a condition of service. See our Privacy Notice and Terms of Use.

Please verify your phone number.

For your security, Growcycle wants to make sure it's really you. Enter the code we sent to .

Finalizing...

Prepare for a contractor call any minute!

Your request has been sent!

We've notified the pro. Expect to hear back shortly.

Want to get more quotes? Select additional pros:

Success, your project
was shared with pros

Check another task off your list.

Browse all services
Retaining Wall Construction
Window Installation & Replacement
Roofing & Gutter Services
Siding & Exterior Remodeling
Solar Panel Installation Services
Pest Control Services
Septic Tank & Septic System Services
Garage Door Installation & Repair
Insulation Installation
Foundation Installation & Repair
Basement Waterproofing
Landscape Design
Landscape Construction
Landscape Maintenance
Landscape Repair
Land Cleaning
Garden Remodeling
Tree Planting & Transplanting
Tree & Shrub Care
Lawn Care & Mowing
Lawn Edging & Trimming
Leaf Removal & Cleanup
Seasonal Yard Cleaning
Lawn Aeration
Lawn Dethatching
Lawn Overseeding & Reseeding
Patio Design & Installation
Paver Installation
Driveway Repair & Paving
Deck Building & Repair
Sidewalk & Pathway Installation
Fence Installation
Stone & Concrete Installation
Outdoor Lighting Installation
Sprinkler Installation & Repair
Sprinkler Adjustment
Drip Irrigation System Installation
Irrigation System Repair
Rainwater Harvesting System Installation
Drought-Resistant Lawn Installation
Handyman Services
Air Duct Cleaning Services
Door Installation & Replacement
Drywall Installation & Repair
House Painting Services
Kitchen Remodeling
Interior Design & Decorating
Custom Cabinets & Cabinetry
Countertop Installation Services
Flooring Installation Services
Tile & Stone Installation Services
Carpet Installation
Bathroom Remodeling
Walk-In Tub Installation
Home Renovation & Remodeling Services
Design-Build Services
Custom Home Builders
Commercial Construction Services
Carpentry & Woodworking
Architectural & Building Design Services
Structural Engineering Services
Heating & Cooling Services
Electrical Services
Plumbing Services
Smart Home & Theater Installers
Professional Home Organizers
Junk Removal & Hauling

Need assistance?

We're here to help you find a pro and get your project done. Leave your contact info and a Growcycle specialist will call you shortly.

You're almost done -- let's keep going!

Or would you prefer we call you?

Location
Browse all services
Retaining Wall Construction
Window Installation & Replacement
Roofing & Gutter Services
Siding & Exterior Remodeling
Solar Panel Installation Services
Pest Control Services
Septic Tank & Septic System Services
Garage Door Installation & Repair
Insulation Installation
Foundation Installation & Repair
Basement Waterproofing
Landscape Design
Landscape Construction
Landscape Maintenance
Landscape Repair
Land Cleaning
Garden Remodeling
Tree Planting & Transplanting
Tree & Shrub Care
Lawn Care & Mowing
Lawn Edging & Trimming
Leaf Removal & Cleanup
Seasonal Yard Cleaning
Lawn Aeration
Lawn Dethatching
Lawn Overseeding & Reseeding
Patio Design & Installation
Paver Installation
Driveway Repair & Paving
Deck Building & Repair
Sidewalk & Pathway Installation
Fence Installation
Stone & Concrete Installation
Outdoor Lighting Installation
Sprinkler Installation & Repair
Sprinkler Adjustment
Drip Irrigation System Installation
Irrigation System Repair
Rainwater Harvesting System Installation
Drought-Resistant Lawn Installation
Handyman Services
Air Duct Cleaning Services
Door Installation & Replacement
Drywall Installation & Repair
House Painting Services
Kitchen Remodeling
Interior Design & Decorating
Custom Cabinets & Cabinetry
Countertop Installation Services
Flooring Installation Services
Tile & Stone Installation Services
Carpet Installation
Bathroom Remodeling
Walk-In Tub Installation
Home Renovation & Remodeling Services
Design-Build Services
Custom Home Builders
Commercial Construction Services
Carpentry & Woodworking
Architectural & Building Design Services
Structural Engineering Services
Heating & Cooling Services
Electrical Services
Plumbing Services
Smart Home & Theater Installers
Professional Home Organizers
Junk Removal & Hauling